Buy Hystories: Hysterical Epidemics and Modern Culture Main Market by Elaine Showalter (ISBN: ) from Amazon’s Book Store. Everyday low. Showalter re-draws the picture of mental illness with clearer lines and as something which is closer to home than some would care to admit. Elaine Showalter. · Rating details · ratings · 9 reviews. This provocative and illuminating book charts the persistence of a cultural phenomenon. Tales of.
|Published (Last):||1 May 2005|
|PDF File Size:||17.92 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||18.12 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
Hysterias, she shows, are always with us, a kind of collective coping mechanism for changing times; all that differs are names and labels, and at times of crisis, individual hysterias can become contagious. The Academic Novel and Its Discontents is a study of the Anglo-American academic novel from the s to the present. Books by Elaine Showalter. Elaine Showalter here discusses a lot of the fads of 90s hysteria, covering a hystorkes variety of familiar topics and pinning them all under the controversial title of “hysteria”: Place Published New York.
Opening hystorries the history of psychiatry’s involvement in hysteria in the time of Charcot and Freud, she traces the replacement of hysteria or conversion reaction by modern hysterical analogues such as: The subject is mass hysteria, or rather the different narratives of social phenomena of hysterical origin, such as Gulf War syndrome, fatigue syndrome, Satanic-ritual-abuse and alien-abduction subcultures and the rest of the sorry farrago of conspiracy-theorist nonsense that passes for culture in America nowadays.
I picked the book up again this time because I was thinking about contemporary anti-vaxxers and how their paranoid behavior presents a larger public health threat — asking myself, ‘are these people hysterical? The concept of “hysteria” was historically applied only to women. Want to Read Currently Reading Read. Josh Barlas rated it it was amazing Oct 31, This book should never have been published, or at least, that section should not have been included.
Freud was the fad-setter of his time, followed by Jacques Lacan, and the trend will continue. This provocative and illuminating book charts the persistence of a cultural phenomenon. Epidemics of hysteria seem to peak at the ends of centuries, when people are already alarmed about social change.
A must read for anyone interested in how moral panics operate. Showalter connects these hysterical events t I had forgotten how much I enjoyed Showalter’s work until I picked up this book recently.
A Jury of Her Peers: This book looks at hysterical epidemics in the s and s in North America, including alien abduction, Chronic fatigue syndrome, Satanic ritual abuse, recovered memory, Gulf War syndrome and multiple personality syndrome. Return to Book Page. But overall, this is a very thought-provoking book that I am sure will rankle various believers but otherwise get people thinking critically.
This article possibly contains original research. Jen Padgett Bohle rated it liked it Sep 28, To her credit, Showalter is most critical of feminists and liberal academics who help confabulate and promote the spread of these ‘hystories’.
Gina rated it it was amazing Jun 24, February Learn how and when to remove this template message. Her book is, in the end, a critique of the contemporary social-science establishment from the inside.
The subject is mass hysteria, or rather the different narratives of social phenomena of hysterical origin, such as Gulf War syndrome, fatigue syndrome, Satanic-ritual-abuse and alien-abduction subcultures and the rest of the sorry farrago of conspiracy-theorist nonsense that passes for culture I’m not, as a rule, a sympathetic reader of feminist literature nor of contemporary criticism. Lists with This Book. This is the kind of alien I want to be abducted by, but as an American, my chances are pretty slim.
She is well known and respected in both academic and popular cultural fields. Just as there is a difference between a soldier with PTSD or ‘shell shock’ and someone who claims their dog has the same condition, this book seems to elide the CFS sufferers into the ‘and my dog’ category.
The third section is well organized and as developed as the first section, but I felt like the conclusion needed to put the history of hysteria that Showalter so expertly develops in the first section into focus with the examples of mass hystories she examines in the third section; as it is, the final concluding chapter feels like a mad rush to get the book into print.
Showalter coined the term “gynocritics” to describe literary criticism based in on a female perspective. Contentious material about living persons that is unsourced or poorly sourced must be removed immediatelyespecially if potentially libelous or harmful.
She argues that women must work both inside and outside the male tradition simultaneously New This book has some value as a way to look at society’s panics and disorders, but it probably should be a way station rather than an endpoint. Dec 26, Vera rated it really liked it. Showalter covers approaches to teaching theory, preparing syllabi and talking about taboo subjects among many other practical topics. However, not enough references for a scholar trying to trace the same path – some very wide assertions made, and no obvious sources on multiple occasions for the random statistics t The work in this book tracing hysteria as a cultural mode, model and concept across two centuries is very astute.
Given that it’s twenty years old, Elaine Showalter’s book seems outdated now–things like Gulf War Syndrome and alien abductions don’t seem to get as much play in the media as they used to, but now we have rumors such as vaccines causing autism a far more dangerous ‘hystory,’ in my opinion, and one which I’m not sure Showalter’s Freudian psychoanalytical approach could explain.
Sarah Stella rated it it was ok Oct 04, The work in this book tracing hysteria as a cultural mode, model and concept across two centuries is very astute. Skillfully surveying the condition of hysteria–its causes, cures, famous patients, and doctors–in the twentieth century, Showalter also looks at literature, drama, and feminist representations of the hysterical. Open Preview See a Problem?
Interesting all around, though often dated in some of the references. Her husband, English Showalter, is a Yale -educated professor of 18th century French literature. What psychologist Roy Schafer calls “retelling a life” is an important part of psychological growth, responsibility, and self-acceptance.
May 26, Evan rated it liked it Shelves: Please improve it by verifying the claims made and adding inline citations.
Writing in the New York Timespsychologist Carol Tavris commented that “In the absence of medical certainty, the belief that all such symptoms are psychological in origin is no improvement over the belief that none of them are. Moi’s criticism was influential as part of a larger debate between essentialist and postmodern feminist theorists at the time.
Hystories: Hysterical Epidemics and Modern Media by Elaine Showalter
In an age skeptical of Freud and the power of unconscious desires and conflicts, personal troubles are blamed on everything from devil-worshipping sadists to conspiring governments.
Feb 08, Kevin Hystoriea rated it really liked it.
Please help by adding reliable sources. Perhaps, yes, it is a form of stress disorder, but the way Showalter frames her ‘scepticism’ however is very unhelpful.
Emma Mc Morrow rated it really liked it Aug 18,